There was a time when Avril Lavigne could sing a track like Nobodys home Her feelings she hides,her dreams she cant find,shes losing her mind,shes falling behind and be believable. She had a fun-filled,Sk8ter boi image,but there was also a melancholy to her songs that resonated with angst-ridden teenagers. However,in her new album,Goodbye Lullaby,she struggles to grow out of her rebellious avatar,yet stay relevant in the world of Katy Perry,Lady Gaga and Lily Allen,where it is all about being unique in an outlandish way. Lavigne is just lost between these two worlds.
This album came out after several production setbacks,including Lavignes divorce from Sum 41 lead singer Deryck Whibley,who has also produced the first half of the album. She promised to be more mature and personal,but the tracks tell a different story: most are forced and not bad ass enough to amaze an average punk-rock fan. The opening track Black Star is a shameless plug for her perfume of the same name. It is a screechy,nursery rhyme-like soundtrack that barely qualifies as a song. Lavigne does not convince anyone when she sings All my life Ive been good but now,Im thinking what the hell. The song is too generic and the lyrics perfunctory. Repetitive vocals and clichés on a loop that clearly belong to a different decade further undermine the lyrics.
I love you or I remember making out,but then I woke up with a new tattoo in Smile is no longer good enough. Lavignes attempts to appeal to a younger and daring audience not only fail spectacularly but they also end up under-utilising her voice. The only track that showcases her vocal abilities is Goodbye,an almost angelic ballad which sounds better than her forced,bad-girl image.
It is not much fun listening to the album and it seems Lavigne didnt have much fun making it either.